The big news from Ruger was the compact SR9, but there was a smaller announcement as well: new versions of the Blackhawk and GP-100 chambered in .327 Federal.
Supposedly the .327 gives outstanding performance with a manageable recoil and, crucially, a skinnier cartridge, which allows more rounds to fit in the cylinder. In the case of the Blackhawk and GP-100, that's 8 and 7 shots, respectively. Don't get me wrong; high-cap revolvers are really neat, and may make the difference for somebody who really likes the feel and operation of a compact wheelgun but isn't comfortable with only five rounds. But for me, at least, that relatively fine difference isn't nearly enough to balance out the inherent disadvantages of a new cartridge: rarity, expense, and the gamble that this new revolutionary cartridge won't go obsolete like so many others. One or two extra rounds in the cylinder simply isn't enough to give the .327 the nod over a .357 or .38sp, a gun I can be absolutely certain will have ammo support for as long as I can buy ammo.
But what about going in the other direction?
What if, instead of making the same size guns hold more ammo, somebody were to make a smaller five-shot .327 revolver? I've handled some old H&R and Iver Johnson pocket revolvers and thought "Man, this would be incredibly handy... if it fired something more serious than .32 S&W." That class of guns was extremely popular in its day, and only went extinct because of their anemic cartridges. Now that we can fit some serious firepower in their chambers, isn't it time for a comeback?
Obviously, designing a whole new gun is a much bigger investment--and therefore a much bigger gamble--than just boring the barrel and cylinder of an existing revolver to a new diameter. And it may be a tough market, what with tiny semiautos being so popular. But if Ruger can find a market for cowboy guns, and Nort American Arms is prepared to gamble on a modern miniature rimfire revolver styled like 19th century pocket guns, there must be enough fans of old-man guns out there to make a subcompact carry revolver worth a try. If Ruger or NAA announced a tiny pocket double action tomorrow, I guarantee Danielle would instantly start jumping through Jersey's hoops to buy one.
There's an actual, bona fide empty niche to be exploited here in the world of handguns, a world where dozens of companies compete to offer minuscule variations on 99-year-old designs, and every major manufacturer tries to pimp its compact black plastic framed double action semiauto as superior to every other company's compact black plastic framed double action semiauto. Let's see some innovation, people!
Friday, January 8, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
See, what we need is a cheap way to produce boutique-caliber ammo. The print-on-demand model for reloading/handloading.
ReplyDeleteWe have that, sort of. Unfortunately, the printers are expensive and labor intensive. ;)
ReplyDeleteI kinda like these .327 Fed guns simply for their versatility. In addition to the .327 you can also fire .32 H&R Mag, .32 S&W Long, .32 S&W, .32 S&W Short, and .32 ACP (am I missing any others?)
ReplyDeleteI love the idea of shooting .32 ACP in a revolver. There's something about firing a pistol cartridge from a revolver without moon clips... It might be the only way that semi-rim ever benefitted anybody.
ReplyDeleteChamber a subcompact pocket revolver in .327, and I'd shoot .32 ACP out of it till my wallet ran dry.
Thing is, NAA's entry is just a riff on their existing mini-revolver, rather than a whole new frame.
ReplyDeleteTo use Smith as a f'rinstance, from the I to the "Improved-I" to the J to the "J-magnum", their smallest frame size has kept pace with the largest round it has to fire, due to economies of scale. The 317 in .22LR uses the same 1.73" cylinder window as the .357 Magnum 360. (The "I" had a 1.515" window and the "J" a 1.645" one.)
Yeah, I haven't handled an Earl in person, and made a false assumption somewhere along the line, probably mentally comparing it to one of those larger old S&W pocket rimfires from the mid 19th century.
ReplyDeleteI understand why nobody's making a compacter revolver for .327--they'd be taking the same gamble I don't want to take on a novel cartridge, but on a much larger scale--but that's the only way I see the cartridge being useful, from my particular perspective.
The I frame is S&W's platform for .32 caliber rounds, isn't it? Is it meaningfully more compact than the J? Am I bitching about a problem that's already solved?
Sorta on the topic , can you fire a 32 S&W LOng out of a old (early 20th century) 32 SW revolver safely? The cylinder is long enough to fit it...
ReplyDeleteAs far as love for old pocket guns, I carry my model 4 S&W in one pocket and and a KelTec 380 in the other :) perfect blend of new and old.
Anon, you know, I have no idea. It probably depends entirely on the specific gun. Their muzzle energy doesn't look wildly different, but I probably wouldn't try it before asking somebody who knows your specific revolver really well.
ReplyDeleteGreat for backpacking. arc-fire trigger - ambi kit
ReplyDeleteSaya lebih menikmati game yang memiliki kontrol sederhana tetapi tetap memberikan tantangan yang menarik untuk diselesaikan. macau resmi slot togel
ReplyDeleteSalah satu kelebihan casino games adalah kemudahan dalam memahami cara bermainnya. Banyak permainan yang menyediakan panduan yang jelas. Ini membantu pemain baru beradaptasi. bandar toto macau
ReplyDeleteCasino games memberikan banyak pilihan hiburan digital. Setiap permainan menawarkan konsep yang berbeda. Tidak heran jika banyak orang tertarik mempelajarinya. iblbet link
ReplyDeleteArtikel tentang casino games seperti ini memberikan informasi yang cukup jelas. Penjelasannya ringan sehingga pembaca bisa memahami pembahasan tanpa harus berhadapan dengan istilah yang terlalu rumit. link togel
ReplyDeletePerkembangan teknologi terus membawa perubahan pada casino games digital. Berbagai inovasi membuat tampilan dan fitur permainan semakin beragam sehingga topiknya menarik untuk diikuti. rajabandot slot
ReplyDeleteCasino games mempunyai banyak konsep yang berbeda dan setiap jenis memiliki ciri khas. Hal tersebut membuat pembahasannya cukup luas dan menarik untuk dipelajari. rajabandot login
ReplyDeletePerkembangan casino games di platform digital cukup menarik untuk diperhatikan. Teknologi modern membawa berbagai perubahan pada fitur dan tampilan permainan. bandar togel online
ReplyDeleteI am usually to blogging i actually appreciate your articles. This content has really peaks my interest. Let me bookmark your web blog and maintain checking for brand new data. BL555
ReplyDeleteNowhere on the Internet is there this much quality and clear information on this subject. How do I know? I know because I’ve searched this topic at length. Thank you. rajabandot login
ReplyDeleteCasino games memiliki berbagai kategori dengan tema yang beragam. Perbedaan tersebut membuat setiap kategori mempunyai ciri khas. Pembahasan seperti ini cukup informatif. togel 4d
ReplyDeleteCasino games mempunyai banyak konsep yang membuat pembahasannya luas. Setiap permainan dapat memiliki tema tersendiri. Keragaman ini cukup menarik untuk diketahui. situs slot gacor
ReplyDeleteWe still cannot quite think We can often be those checking important points positioned on your webblog. Our kids and that i are sincerely thankful on your generosity and then for giving me possibility pursue our chosen profession path. Just material Managed to get on the web-site. Vivet kai cenat
ReplyDeleteHARGATOTO is known as the center of the official gacor slot bookmaker and a trusted toto togel site that presents a gaming experience with a modern system and stable access at all times. situs slot
ReplyDeleteArtikel mengenai casino games ini terasa informatif. Penjelasan berbagai kategori cukup sederhana. Pembahasannya mudah dipahami. macau slot online
ReplyDeletePerkembangan casino games memperlihatkan semakin beragamnya desain digital. Setiap permainan memiliki tampilan tersendiri. Informasi tersebut cukup informatif. bandar slot maxwin
ReplyDeleteCasino games mempunyai berbagai kategori dengan karakteristik yang berbeda. Setiap kategori menawarkan konsep visual tersendiri. Keragaman tersebut membuat topiknya tidak monoton. situs slot online
ReplyDeleteLynk id is the official lynk id account of Katsu5 We are an online slot game provider site katsu5 resmi
ReplyDeleteArtikel mengenai casino games ini cukup mudah dipahami. Informasinya disampaikan dengan bahasa sederhana. Penjelasannya terasa ringan. bandar slot
ReplyDeleteCasino games mempunyai daya tarik tersendiri dari sisi desain permainan. Berbagai permainan menggunakan konsep dan tampilan yang berbeda. Pembahasan mengenai variasinya cukup menarik untuk dibaca. situs togel online
ReplyDelete